Page 3 of 5

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2009 3:16 pm
by darph nader
GRUMPY PIRATE wrote:The third stage to recovery is realizing that life is too short to worry about small stuff, and just do what you want!
The fourth step is trying to figure what the hell everyone is talking about. :confused: Excuse me while I go listen to my 45rpm singles. :rolleyes:

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2009 6:20 pm
by hobie16
Sioban wrote:As odd as it may sound, have you tried to throw it without too much force against a carpeted floor? My 2nd gen iPod gave me the dreaded sad iPod icon.
Rather than brute force I tried reformatting in Disk Utility and reloading the iPod OS. That worked.

I then synced the iTunes library to the iPod. It gets about one third done and I hear a gawd awful grinding noise. The iPod freezes up and I get the folder icon followed by the unhappy iPod icon.

It looks like the hard disk has had a major media failure.

The Touch arrived yesterday. Wowsers! What a leap forward. I may buy a new drive for Old Faithful just to see if I can resurrect it.

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 12:06 am
by GRUMPY PIRATE
hobie16 wrote:Rather than brute force I tried reformatting in Disk Utility and reloading the iPod OS. That worked.

I then synced the iTunes library to the iPod. It gets about one third done and I hear a gawd awful grinding noise. The iPod freezes up and I get the folder icon followed by the unhappy iPod icon.

It looks like the hard disk has had a major media failure.

The Touch arrived yesterday. Wowsers! What a leap forward. I may buy a new drive for Old Faithful just to see if I can resurrect it.
you MIGHT also try the refrigerator trick.

when we are trying to acquire data off a HDD that has some reading problems, we stick the hdd in the refrigerator for about an hour, then pull in out hook it up and start acquiring sectors until it stops, then back in the fridge!

it is a slow process, but it works, especialy if you need the data on the HDD.

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 3:37 am
by Main Streeter
darph nader wrote:The fourth step is trying to figure what the hell everyone is talking about. :confused:
:hysteria: Was wondering how much you could take. When you'd crack & post. Too funny darph. :D:

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 8:40 am
by hobie16
GRUMPY PIRATE wrote:you MIGHT also try the refrigerator trick.

when we are trying to acquire data off a HDD that has some reading problems, we stick the hdd in the refrigerator for about an hour, then pull in out hook it up and start acquiring sectors until it stops, then back in the fridge!

it is a slow process, but it works, especialy if you need the data on the HDD.
Luckily, the whole idea of the iPods is the data (music) is held on the Mac and copied to the iPod.

I've never heard a drive grind like this one and I worked for a data storage company.

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 9:55 am
by ktulu
hobie16 wrote:Luckily, the whole idea of the iPods is the data (music) is held on the Mac and copied to the iPod.

I've never heard a drive grind like this one and I worked for a data storage company.
You probably never carried those drives around all the time while they were spinning either ;)

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 9:58 am
by hobie16
ktulu wrote:You probably never carried those drives around all the time while they were spinning either ;)
Nope. :D: We used Seagates with fiber channel that were inside of a metal cassette. Those suckers were heavy!

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 10:30 am
by Cranbiz
Too bad we are now using who is cheapest. I'm sending out way too many replacements for the Fujitsu's, Hitachi's, etc.

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 10:40 am
by hobie16
Cranbiz wrote:Too bad we are now using who is cheapest. I'm sending out way too many replacements for the Fujitsu's, Hitachi's, etc.
Even Seagate is suspect. We bought the most expensive drives that were QA'd up the wazoo to last forever. Meanwhile, some schlub off the street bought a Seagate from Joe Baggadonuts Deli and Data Emporium and saw it fail within a year.

Re: RIP iPod

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2009 11:24 am
by GRUMPY PIRATE
hobie16 wrote:Luckily, the whole idea of the iPods is the data (music) is held on the Mac and copied to the iPod.

I've never heard a drive grind like this one and I worked for a data storage company.
some times it works.

its a last ditch effort to recover the data, if that dosn't work we open up the drive, take the platters out and put them in a new case.